Anyone who saw Zenyatta’s remarkable triumph in the Breeders’ Cup Classic can not deny it was a performance for the ages and one many people now feel deems her worthy of Horse of the Year honors. Before anyone hands her the trophy, however, lets recap what another top female performer had already pulled off this season.
What Rachel Alexandra accomplished in 2009 goes beyond the borders of extraordinary. She ran and won eight times this year over seven different tracks. She beat males three, count ‘em, three times including the remarkable feat of taking down older males in the Woodward. By the time Zenyatta even began her five-race campaign in late May Rachel Alexandra had already scored four graded stakes wins including her 20 1/4 length romp in the Kentucky Oaks and her one-length triumph in the Preakness two weeks later which, by the way, came after she went through the stress of switching barns and being in a completely new environment only days before what was then the biggest race of her life.
Some have tried to argue that for all of Rachel Alexandra’s triumphs this year, she really didn’t beat much. Well, prior to her Breeders’ Cup triumph, Zenyatta had defeated a grand total of two Grade I winners this year (Life Is Sweet and Cocoa Beach).
Rachel Alexandra, by comparison, had defeated the Kentucky Derby winner in Mine That Bird, was six lengths in front of the Belmont, Travers, and Jockey Club Gold Cup winner Summer Bird, beat the Stephen Foster winner (Macho Again), the Whitney winner (Bullsbay), a UAE Triple Crown winner (Asiatic Boy) as well as the Santa Anita Derby winner (Pioneerof the Nile) and a horse who has gone on to become a multiple Grade I winner on the turf (Take the Points). And that’s just the boys. Gabby’s Golden Gal, the filly Rachel Alexandra crushed when she went by her like a rocket in the Kentucky Oaks, came back to win the Grade I Acorn on the Belmont Stakes undercard.
As solid as the Breeders’ Cup Classic field was, it wasn’t terribly more challenging than anything Rachel Alexandra had already faced. Summer Bird and Mine That Bird were back. There was Einstein, who had gotten beat by Macho Again in the Stephen Foster; Awesome Gem, a solid handicap horse but by no means a monster; Colonel John, making just his fourth start this year and who hadn’t won a graded stakes race since the 2008 Travers; Richard’s Kid, again solid, but no world-beater, and Grade II winners Regal Ransom and Girolamo. The only major upgrades were four-time Grade I winner Gio Ponti, who starred on the turf this year, and European invaders Twice Over and Rip Van Winkle. And Quality Road literally melted down before he could even get in the gate.
Also, Rachel Alexandra rattled off all her feats as a 3-year-old filly whereas Zenyatta is an older, stronger 5-year-old mare.
Some will hold the fact Rachel Alexandra did not run in the Breeders’ Cup against her, but you can not blame her for the decisions the humans around her make. And considering she had already had a far more rigorous campaign than any of her rivals, you also can’t fault an owner for wanting to give his prized filly a well-deserved break.
This year has presented the racing world with two amazing, once-in-a-lifetime horses in Rachel Alexandra and Zenyatta and hopefully, when the ballots come out, we voters will be able to split our votes so that both may be rewarded the Horse of the Year honor they each deserve.
But if push comes to shove and I have to choose, I’m going with the filly who ran more, won more, and beat more. Because as sad as it would be to see Zenyatta not gain a Horse of the Year prize, it would be an absolute travesty if the historic feats Rachel Alexandra accomplished this year were rewarded with anything less than the highest honor.